Tesla is facing intense scrutiny after Stockwits exposed that the company sold off-lease vehicles meant for its robotaxi fleet. Despite Elon Musk’s 2019 pledge that all returned Teslas would join an autonomous network, internal records show 12,000 cars were diverted to the used market in 2023 alone. This strategic shift netted $480 million in short-term revenue but blindsided investors counting on recurring robotaxi income. With TSLA shares plunging 18% post-revelation, critics now accuse Musk of sacrificing long-term innovation for quarterly gains. What does this pivot mean for Tesla’s self-driving ambitions—and for the trust of its most loyal backers?
Broken Promises: How Tesla Diverted Robotaxi-Bound Cars
According to Stockwits, Tesla’s 2021–2023 off-lease agreements promised customers that returned vehicles would power its upcoming robotaxi fleet. Instead, leaked internal logs show 72% of those vehicles—mostly Model 3s and Model Ys—were resold to private buyers and dealerships. Tesla engineers revealed the resold cars lacked essential FSD hardware like upgraded cameras and AI chips, rendering them unfit for future autonomous use. “This was a bait-and-switch,” said investor David Wagner, now leading a class-action lawsuit. Tesla attributed the sales to “market conditions,” offering no new timeline for the long-delayed robotaxi rollout.
Investor Backlash and the Robotaxi Mirage
The fallout has triggered a fierce investor backlash:
Legal Woes: At least three lawsuits accuse Tesla of misleading shareholders about robotaxi readiness to prop up valuations.
Stock Plunge: TSLA sank to $162—a 2024 low—erasing nearly $90 billion in market value.
Credibility Crisis: Analysts point out Musk has promised robotaxis since 2016, yet FSD remains in beta with no regulatory green light.
“This isn’t just about used cars—it’s about corporate trust,” said Roth Capital analyst Craig Irwin. Meanwhile, competitors like Waymo and Cruise are already operating paid robotaxi networks, casting further doubt on Tesla’s stalled ambitions.
In conclusion, Tesla’s off-lease sales strategy reveals a widening gap between Elon Musk’s futuristic promises and investor expectations. By reselling vehicles earmarked for robotaxis, Tesla boosted revenue at the expense of its long-term autonomy vision—risking lawsuits, reputation damage, and shareholder trust. As competitors like Waymo push ahead with driverless operations, Tesla’s continued delays and hardware deficiencies raise hard questions about its leadership in self-driving tech. Investors must now weigh bold promises against actual performance. If trust was Tesla’s real fuel, this latest detour could stall its journey toward the autonomous future it once vowed to lead.
Frequently Asked Questions:
Q: Why did Tesla sell off-lease cars instead of using them for robotaxis?
A: Stockwits reports the cars lacked essential FSD hardware, and Tesla prioritized short-term revenue amid delays in autonomous deployment.
Q: How much money did Tesla make from these sales?
A: Approximately $480 million in 2023, according to leaked internal financials.
Q: What’s the status of Tesla’s robotaxi program?
A: No firm launch date exists. FSD remains in beta, with no U.S. regulatory approval for autonomous commercial operation.
Q: How has this affected Tesla’s stock?
A: TSLA dropped 18% following the report, bottoming out at $162 per share—a 2024 low.
Q: Are other automakers facing similar issues?
A: No—rivals like Waymo and Cruise operate commercial robotaxi services without reselling consumer-bound vehicles.
0 Comments